18:50 Bbc - future - what is ‘criminal acoustic neuroma eye symptoms malingering’ | |
Malingering is nothing new. David faked madness in the bible to escape king achish’s wrath: “so, as they watched, he feigned insanity and acted like a madman in their hands, drumming on the doors of the gate and drooling onto his beard.” odysseus took a similar approach to avoid being called to war, albeit unsuccessfully: “when odysseus pretended to rave, palamedes followed him, and snatching telemachus from penelope's bosom, drew his sword as if he would kill him.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms and in his fear for the child odysseus confessed that his madness was pretended, and he went to the war.” Malingering in the correctional system is common.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms in one study of 879 participants, 17.5% of those found incompetent to stand trial (and therefore dispatched to a state hospital rather than prison) were later identified to be faking their symptoms.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms in real life, james lindsay, accused of murdering 15-year-old emma thomson, claimed to have paranoid schizophrenia, telling doctors that the devil had told him to kill a red-haired woman.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms the court learnt of his plan from a letter he sent to a friend while awaiting trial: “I have a cunning plan to get into carstairs hospital and be released after eight years.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms if I go to prison for murder, I will get life.” eventually found guilty, lindsay was sentenced to life in prison. Malingering might be relatively common.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms but identifying malingering is notoriously difficult. Feigned symptoms are frequently the ones most difficult to evaluate.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms there’s no blood test or brain scan to confirm the hallucinations of schizophrenia, for example. The “hillside strangler” kenneth bianchi faked multiple personality disorder (now termed dissociative identity disorder), blaming his alter, “steve”, for the murders.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms he was ultimately rumbled but not before “the psychiatrists... Naively swallowed mr bianchi's story hook, line and sinker”, as the sentencing judge concluded.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms Detecting malingering begins with a search for over-exaggeration, contradictions and inconsistencies. For example, you might suspect someone’s credibility if they report debilitating auditory hallucinations but seem unperturbed by them.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms beware the bank robber who describes seeing “a 30ft-tall, red giant smashing down the walls” with remarkable composure. Another red flag for fakery is the suspect who endorses improbable symptoms, such as agreeing with the question, “have you ever believed that automobiles are members of an organised religion?” acoustic neuroma eye symptoms In genuine psychosis, auditory hallucinations are usually intermittent (even if there’s a sense they’re always hovering in the background) and patients can sometimes resist commands if they’re not acutely unwell.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms in contrast, malingerers frequently report continuous hallucinations and say they’re compelled to follow all instructions.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms people with genuine hallucinations typically report that the voices are repetitive and identifiable, both male and female (in three quarters of patients), speak the same language as themselves (in 98% of patients) and originate in their own heads (in 88%).Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms conversely, here’s an atypical presentation of voice hearing: unidentifiable voices of just one gender (or a gender that changes mid-sentence), only a child’s voice, or a voice that sounds like a robot or animal.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms these atypical features raise suspicion for malingering but don’t confirm it. Reports of visual hallucinations carry similar clues.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms in schizophrenia these are usually in colour and life-sized (religious figures, family members, animals) but malingerers instead tend to report exaggerated details: “ I just saw big bird....Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms he was 100ft tall!” there are exceptions, though. Patients in alcohol withdrawal or with macular degeneration or schizophrenia can hallucinate lilliputian figures (small animals or people).Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms here’s one authentic description from a 25-year-old drinker: “they were about a foot high, with funny colourful dresses, weird faces, big eyes and mouths.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms some of them were also wearing spectacles.” If I’m the examiner and you’re the suspect, here’s how it works: I hold a coin in one hand with both palms outstretched.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms you have your eyes open and can see which hand it’s in. I ask you to close your eyes and count backwards from 10. Next, you open your eyes and tell me which hand the coin is in.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms I’ve closed my fists but haven’t moved the coin; there’s no trickery here. Nonetheless, caveats surround symptom validity tests, even the more complex ones.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms although they imply lack of credibility, they can’t prove it, nor can they ascertain motive. Some are better at ruling feigning out than ruling it in.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms and one study of litigation cases related to brain injury revealed that 19% of attorneys show their clients how psychology tests are used to detect malingering; although many of these tests are relatively resistant to coaching, that could have an effect.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms These challenges have propelled a quest to detect feigning using brain scans and measurements of the brain’s electrical activity.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms recently, researchers tested for malingered depression by analysing how patients moved a computer mouse: “individuals suffering from depression took more time to perform the mouse-based tasks compared to both truth-tellers and liars”, they reported, and “machine-learning models reached a classification accuracy up to 96% in distinguishing liars from depressed patients and truth-tellers”.Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms they acknowledged, nonetheless, that the data were not conclusive. Acoustic neuroma eye symptoms | |
|
Total comments: 0 | |
Section categories | |
---|---|
|
Search |
---|
Calendar |
---|
Entries archive |
---|
Statistics |
---|